I have an idea. I'll take guard and GE Music. Corndog can take Music Ensemble. That leaves GEV if someone else wants to take two. Does that work?

I can take GEV if nobody wants to do two, while I'm probably not gonna be a regular judge this season, I'm not too busy this week

I'm down with that!

Perfect! Here is the judging panel.


Brass: gcurrier

Percussion: liebling82

Music Ensemble: corndogshuffle

Visual Performance: Chapstick

Guard: Aaron0316

Visual Ensemble: cjbuckley1997

GE Music: Aaron0316

GE Visual: theamazing1

The deadline to submit scores is Sunday, August 14 :)

Now that we have only one judge for everything, do you think we need a second DCI judge across the board?

We can try it without the second DCI judge. Part of the reason we used the DCI judge was to keep people from going rogue and drastically making someone lose or win - much like it seems some of these DCI judges do! (lol) Anyway, I believe, we have an honest, reasonable panel of judges.

But if we eliminate the DCI judge, how about we share some of our observations and opinions? After the results, I'd like us to share, if possible, how we came up with our scores. Obviously it's not a requirement. If you're too busy and can't share or if you don't want to share, it's fine.

Yeah I really like that, because especially with certain captions, I'm always thinking something that helps me come to my final score, and it would be really cool to share it

I want to remind the judges who haven't submitted their scores that the deadline is this Sunday. Thanks for participating this week.

Hello, all, the scores are due today. I'm in the process of making the spreadsheet. If you still want to submit scores, please try to have them in soon. Thanks.

Please let me know if you want me to wait a bit longer before I post these results.

I haven't judged vp yet. I will have my scores to you in a few. Sorry.

Sending my scores in 15

*** Round 1 Results ***

This probably comes as no surprise, but The Cadets 1990 won and automatically advance to the final round.

Awards:

The Cadets swept all the awards


1st - The Cadets 1990 - 97.24

2nd - Madison Scouts 2013 - 94.575

3rd - Crossmen 2015 - 92.53


RECAP - https://1drv.ms/x/s!AqYsp918aiERgVdC0Wd0_vVtWL3D


*** Round 2 Match Up ***

Carolina Crown 2006 - https://onedrive.live.com/?authkey=%21AOSEobVYkMtgKR0&cid=8C66477F54959A85&id=8C66477F54959A85%21270&parId=8C66477F54959A85%21107&o=OneUp

Bluecoats 2007 - https://onedrive.live.com/?authkey=%21AOSEobVYkMtgKR0&cid=8C66477F54959A85&id=8C66477F54959A85%21268&parId=8C66477F54959A85%21107&o=OneUp

Star of Indiana 1993 - https://onedrive.live.com/?authkey=%21AOSEobVYkMtgKR0&cid=8C66477F54959A85&id=8C66477F54959A85%21269&parId=8C66477F54959A85%21107&o=OneUp


*** Current Standings ***

1st - The Cadets 1990 - (A) 97.24
2nd - Madison Scouts 2013 - 94.575
3rd - Crossmen 2015 - 92.53

Oooh I'll take visual GE. This will likely be my last week judging for a while, but I'll make it good!

I know I stated that I'd like for us to choose a different caption each round. I want to make an exception for those who only specialize in a few captions. At least, try to pick two and alternate each round. I don't have a problem with judging any caption.

I'll take percussion this week

Hey I could probably do this this week again. I'll take music ensemble

Aaron I can do anything besides guard and possibly percussion (not my strong suit but I could do it). Slot me in wherever works best for you besides guard and I'll make it work!

Okay, this is what we have, so far.


Brass: corndog (Are you okay with that?)

Perc: gcurrer

ME: theamazing1

VP: ?

Guard: ?

VE: Aaron0316

GEM: ?

GEV: cjbuckley


If anyone on FMA is reading this post, feel free to join the judging panel.