I'm not sure the video is exactly the loud thing with the Blue Devils. (;

Okay so I have an idea for the next competition. What if we did a battle of the corps? The preliminary rounds would be shows from different years for the same corps (like Carolina Crown, say 2008, 2011, 2013 and 2014), and the best show from each corps would move on to the finals. I know that on the link we've been getting the shows from, there are at least 6 corps that have three shows or more, so it would be very interesting.

I like your idea, and we totally will do it, just not next season. Rhythmicthinking has shared a collection of marching band videos that I want to use for season 46.

Ohh okay. I doubt I'll be able to judge next season anyway, with school and band and such

No problem.. This is just something to do in one's free time, anyway.

Judges, if you plan to judge, the deadline is coming very soon. Try to have your scores submitted no later than 7 PM Eastern Time on Saturday, August 29. I want to wrap this up around the same time scores are posted for FMA finals.

The results are in ....


Best Brass - Star of Indiana 1991

Best Percussion - Santa Clara Vanguard 2014

Best Colorguard - Blue Devils 2011

Best Music - Santa Clara Vanguard 2014

Best Visual - Blue Devils 2011

Best GE - Star of Indiana 1991


7th - 94.0000 - The Cadets 2012

6th - 95.2875 - Carolina Crown 2008

5th - 96.2000 - Phantom Regiment 2012

4th - 96.5250 - Star of Indiana 1991


3rd - 96.5500 - Santa Clara Vanguard 2014

2nd - 96.9125 - Blue Devils 2011

1st - 97.0000 - The Cavaliers 2011!!!!


Full Recap on OneDrive here -----> http://1drv.ms/1Jtbsup

Interesting to see the finals results. Thanks everyone for participating!

Whoa!

That's quite an upset. I love it lol rhythmic our percussion scores were really close. good judging

What? I quit lol

Wait. Somethings wrong....those aren't my scores

Yeah I know my scores by heart and they're in the GE Music, not visual

(LOL) The scores are right. Switch the words around and your scores are correct. I was working quickly to get the scores out. I did GE Visual first and put those scores under GE MUsic on the spreadsheet and forgot to edit the caption name. Even though your scores are mislabeled, they are as you wanted them. The outcome doesn't change. You and cjbuckley had Star winning GE Visual with a 19.75.

Because we know what we were talking about! Lol

I remember this was really fun, anyone wanna bring it back for next season?

I'd be down for doing this again

I'd like to run it honestly, since Aaron isn't active anymore. I got a bunch of new dci videos and I have a few ideas for cool themes

Long time, no see, judges! Are you ready for more action? Several seasons ago, someone emailed a list of videos. I want to put these marching bands head to head. Each week, one band will win and advance to finals. Finals will be in week 5. The highest scoring eliminated band will compete at finals.

Scoring is exactly as it is on FMA. Both GE captions are 20 a piece. All other captions are worth 10. Ideally I want two judges per caption, but depending on how many participate, I will accept three. All judges scores will be averaged. Remember to please send your scores to me privately. AND FYI, you may judge two captions! Our first match up is....


Cedar Park 2013 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EvcOkIdHLDM

vs.

Carmel 2012 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CC4fMm4Axw4


Judges:

Winds: liebling82
Percussion: Chapstick
Music Ensemble: theamazing1
GE Music: Aaron0316, cjbuckley1997

Visual Performance: liebling82
Color Guard: Aaron0316, Tromboning
Visual Ensemble: Chapstick
GE VIsual: theamazing1

You have until Sunday to submit scores. Thank you, and happy judging.

I can judge winds. I'll judge another too if you need it

Can I do GE visual and Music ensemble